Thursday, November 7, 2013

Pete The Crumb Talks Murder And Mob History

By George Anastasia
For Bigtrial.net

He was described by the defense as an 84-year-old Mafia hitman with a faulty memory, a mobster who had murdered so often "he couldn't remember how many people he had killed."

But when he took the stand this afternoon in the racketeering conspiracy trial of crime boss Joe Ligambi and wiseguy George Borgesi, Peter "Pete the Crumb" Caprio rattled off the how, when and why of a series of hits that are part of his organized crime resume.

Thin, balding and hard of hearing, Caprio was the leadoff witness for the prosecution in the retrial of the two Philadelphia mob leaders. Dressed in a blue V-neck sweater over a shirt and tie, Caprio spent 90 minutes on the stand at the end of the trial day. He is due back when the trial resumes next Tuesday.

"Shoot him again to make sure he's dead," Caprio said matter-of-factly as he recounted the instructions he gave to an associate during the 1975 slaying of a mob associate known as Butchie whose remains were dropped in a shallow grave in the basement of a Newark social club and then covered with cement.
Caprio said he was a member of the North Jersey branch of the Philadelphia crime family and identified both Ligambi and Borgesi as leaders of the organization. He said he was elevated to the rank of capo or captain after orchestrating the 1996 murder of Joe Sodano, a long-time capo who had failed to fall in line under the leadership of Ralph Natale and Joseph "Skinny Joey" Merlino in the mid 1990s.

Caprio's trip down memory lane was a reprise of testimony he had given on at least two other occasions in federal courtrooms in Philadelphia. He testified at a racketeering trial in 2001 in which both Merlino and Borgesi were convicted.

And he was a witness last year in the racketeering trial of Ligambi, Borgesi and five others. A split verdict and a hung jury on conspiracy charges against Ligambi and Borgesi led to the retrial that opened this morning. Ligambi also faces gambling and obstruction of justice counts.

Many of those in the courtroom, including prosecutors, FBI agents, members of the media and the defendants and their friends and family members had heard Caprio's stories before. But for the twelve jurors and six alternates the testimony was new and, the prosecution hoped, would provide the foundation for the rest of its case.

"This case is about how the mob makes money," Assistant U.S. Attorney Frank Labor told the jury in his opening statement at the start of the trial day.

Labor spent a little over an hour laying out the allegations against Ligambi and Borgesi and offering the jury what amounted to a legal primer on the nature of a conspiracy charge. The simple fact that Ligambi and Borgesi agreed that a crime should be committed by someone else was enough to support a guilty verdict, he argued.

Both defendants, as leaders of the Philadelphia branch of Cosa Nostra, benefitted from the gambling, loansharking and extortion carried out by others, he said. And the government's case, based on secretly recorded conversations and the testimony of cooperating witnesses -- including two undercover FBI agents and several admitted mobsters like Caprio -- would support those charges.

Defense attorneys offered a decidedly different take on the same set of circumstances.

Edwin Jacobs Jr., the lawyer for Ligambi, said the government's allegations were built around implausible theories and unsubstantiated testimony from less than credible witnesses.

Jacobs used a quote from Abraham Lincoln in a legal argument offered in a case 150 years ago.

"My adversary's case is as thin as the broth made from a starving chicken," he said.

He described the government's witnesses as liars and thugs who had cut deals to get out from under criminal charges they faced. Ticking off a list of witnesses who are scheduled to take the stand during the six week trial, Jacobs described one as a hitman who committed so many murders "he can't even remember how many people he killed." Another, he said, was a violent thug and a "convicted perjurer."And a third was a serial bank robber who cut a cooperating agreement with the government, was freed from prison and then went out and robbed some more banks.

Those witnesses, in order, were Caprio, Louis "Bent Finger Lou" Monacello and Anthony Aponick.

Christopher Warren, Borgesi's lawyer, spent most of his opening blistering Monacello and Apronick, the two key witnesses in the case against Borgesi.

Like Caprio, Monacello testified at the trial last year. Aponick, a cellmate of Borgesi's in a federal prison in West Virginia between 2001 and 2003, will be making his debut in the current case.

Warren said Aponick, an associate of the Bonanno crime family in New York, viewed Borgesi as his "get out of jail free card" and fabricated information to work a deal with the FBI. And even after he committed the second set of bank robberies and violated the terms of his cooperating agreement, the government took him back as a witness because they were desperate to make a case against Borgesi.

"They took somebody they had kicked out of their bed and put him back under the covers," Warren argued, "because they didn't have anything better."

Monacello, a South Philadelphia mob associate, used Borgesi's name and reputation to advance his own gambling and loansharking operations, which Warren argued, Borgesi knew nothing about. He called Monacello "an egomaniacal blowhard" and a "petty bully" who enjoyed beating up and assaulting others.

Both witnesses are "frauds," Warren said. Aponick, he told the jury, "will try to sell you a bill of goods. Don't buy it."

George Anastasia can be contacted at George@bigtrial,.net.

18 comments:

  1. Thank you for truthful reporting.

    ReplyDelete
  2. How the hell do you paint a pic of these witnesses but not the criminals. My God its so obvious that Georgie Boy was involved with these guys .im sure Aponick didnt just come to philly for a cup of joe ..a new york mobster just happened to run into Georgies brother & Georgies Boys rite hand man bent finger.Lou Monecello .the Rat .& for the record Georgie Boys wife calls him a Rat omg how stupid why would u call l this ben finger a rat if he had nothing to do with ur hubby .Georgie Boy must be guilty of something. It doesn't take a rocket science to figure that out.call him a goof ..fuck finger the finger that Georgie Boy im sure liked at one time lol but a Rat that just goes to show just how GUILTY GEORGIE BOY REALLY IS.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. excellent point, but not substantive enough to foster a guilty verdict!

      Delete
  3. I seriously doubt George Borgesi is guilty of the crimes they are accusing him of. This man has been in prison since 2000, all his meetings and calls are monitored. There is nothing he can run. Nothing! Let this poor man go home to his family. This is pathetic.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So I guess Aponick set up that meeting with Monacello by himself? Borgesi is not some victim of the government. He is a long time member of organized crime and is linked to several killings in the 1990s, and has been linked to the Rocco Maniscalco hit in 2010. Joseph Massimino was imprisoned for a chunk of the time period the indictment covers, did you think he was a victim too? These guys are scumbags and hopefully they get nailed.

      Delete
    2. I agree but I would love to see him come out for just a week or two if he last that long & try to take back his gambling territory. That would be PRICELESS.

      Delete
  4. They have nothing on George or Joe. It's incredible what the government is doing here. Absolutely astounding.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Do u get conjigal visits eith him

      Delete
  5. ??????????^^^^^^^^^^^

    ReplyDelete
  6. Joe and George both did their time for their past convictions. What do they have on them now? The government is fishing for things that are non exist-ant. George was found not guilty of 13, out of 14 counts, but the Judge does not want that to be allowed to be brought up in court. If it does, its a miss trial. hmmm?? oh, that i just love the thought of the government giving some 90 year old murderer tens of thousands of dollars, plus free health care just to go up on the podium and speak about stories his (and only his) when he was 2 years of age until he was 40 years of age. What does that have to do with ANYTHING in the present? nothing!!! Prosecutors just wanted the jurors to go home to a long weekend thinking about "The Mob" and what they are about instead of FACTS! If i were a Juror on this case i would think to myself that my time is being wasted listening to this Bull Sh*t. Its pathetic. The government are the true BULLYS. Whatever people had done in their past, they serve their time and thats that.... what is the reasoning for this. Recharging someone for things they either were found NOT guilty of, OR already did the time for is absurd. Thats actually Double Jeopardy and illegal !!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They will do anything to abolish the competition. They will soon control the sports gambling the same way they took over the lottery! George will never impugn them though, because he is biased.

      Delete
  7. ?????????????...^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

    ReplyDelete
  8. BOY GEORGE better hope he gets another 14 with some of nickys boys out his ass isnt worth a fiddlers F--k

    ReplyDelete
  9. A Wise Prosecutor Does Not Build His or Her Case on Crumbs! Perhaps That Deficiency is the Reason for This Second Go-Around. George, You Sound Like a Cartoon Character When You Speak - You Punk Heat-Merchant!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Pete the Crumb is POS rat and a fanook

    ReplyDelete
  11. I have always liked your columns and books George, but even you have to admit that this case is really just a gambling case at its heart. There is no way this should even gotten vthis far. I truly believe they brought Rico charges just to explain why they spent 10 years and millions of taxpayer money on this case.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Poor Georgie wants to go home,how about the guys he whacked ,are they going home.As long as Georgie keeps berating these feds they will stop at nothing to put him away.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I love how all these DUNCES come over here from GangsterBB and act like they know whats really going on. Whats wrong with you jerkoffs? GET A FUCKING LIFE.

    ReplyDelete

Thoughtful commentary welcome. Trolling, harassing, and defaming not welcome. Consistent with 47 U.S.C. 230, we have the right to delete without warning any comments we believe are obscene, lewd, lascivious, filthy, excessively violent, harassing, or otherwise objectionable, whether or not such material is constitutionally protected.

 

Big Trial | Philadelphia Trial Blog Copyright © 2016 BigTrial.net

Privacy Policy: BigTrial.net does not distribute, share or sell email addresses, or any other personal information received from this website.